Lost something in Old Tappan? Here are the offices that take your report.
One report to the Old Tappan Police Department, NJ Transit if applicable, and active local channels. Your report stays active, automatically matching against new found items.
What did you lose?
If there isn’t an adequate suggestion, select “Other – My item isn’t listed” and enter the item’s category. You can provide details later.
Publishing your report is free and your details stay private. The assisted search is a separate paid service, described in the Terms.
Recent activity
Across the United States
- Wrislet clutch gray/silver bag with documents · Chicago, IL, October 8
- Ring TM on top · Greensboro, NC, October 8
- Keys · Sarasota, FL, October 8
- Keys · Brookline, MA, October 7
- Camera · Monterey, CA, October 7
Local contact details reviewed on October 7, 2026.
How ReportLost Works
You report your loss
Tell us what you lost, when, and where in Old Tappan. We gather all the details needed to notify the right agencies and channels.
We route it to the right places
Your report goes to the Old Tappan Police Department, NJ Transit lost and found if it was on a bus, and local community channels. No need to figure out who to call.
Your report keeps searching
For up to 12 months, your report stays active and cross-checks new found items posted online and reported to local authorities. We alert you the moment there's a potential match.
Where to Report in Old Tappan
If you prefer to report directly, here are the main channels. ReportLost handles all of this for you.
Old Tappan Police Department
The local police maintain a lost and found for items recovered or turned in by residents and businesses. Report any loss here to create an official record. We generate the correct details and point you to the right desk if you're handling it yourself.
Old Tappan Borough Hall
Borough Hall can direct you to relevant departments and may have information about items turned in at municipal facilities. Staff can help you navigate local resources.
NJ Transit Lost & Found
If you lost something on a bus or at a transit stop, NJ Transit has a dedicated lost and found system. You can report online, by phone, or in person. We tell you how to file your claim and follow up on status.
Lost Pet Report
If you've lost a dog, cat, or other pet in Old Tappan, alert animal control and local pet networks immediately. Time is critical for pets. Tyco Animal Control serves the area, and community groups monitor pet posts closely.
Tyco Animal Control|<a href="/report-lost-pet"><strong>File a priority lost pet report</strong></a>
Newark Airport (EWR)
If you lost an item at Newark Liberty International Airport or on a flight, EWR has a dedicated lost and found office. Contact them directly with your flight details and item description.
⚠️ Spotted incorrect or outdated information? Let us know so we can review it.
Get Your Report Started
The sooner you report, the sooner the search begins. Filing your report takes just a few minutes, and we handle the rest while your report stays active in the background.
Report my lost item →Losing something in Old Tappan means contacting multiple places: the police, transit authorities, shops, and hoping someone posts it on Facebook. It's scattered, time-consuming, and you can easily miss updates while checking back constantly.
ReportLost simplifies this. One report, and we notify the Old Tappan Police Department, NJ Transit services, and active local community channels on your behalf. Better yet, your report doesn't disappear after a week, it stays active and continues matching against newly found items for months, so you don't have to be the one refreshing pages every day.
Common Places Items Are Lost in Old Tappan
These are spots where people frequently lose wallets, keys, phones, and other valuables.
Downtown & Shopping Areas
Retail stores, parking lots, and street-facing businesses along the main commercial corridors are common hotspots for lost wallets and personal items.
Parks & Recreation Facilities
Walking trails, playgrounds, and sports facilities see items left behind during activities. Joggers and families often lose rings, bracelets, and phones here.
Transit Stops & Bus Routes
NJ Transit bus stops and routes through Old Tappan are frequent loss points. Items are left on buses, at shelters, or during transfers.
Residential Streets & Neighborhoods
Items slip out of pockets or bags while walking around the tree-lined residential areas. Many are found by neighbors and turned in to police.
Local Restaurants & Cafés
Phones, wallets, and glasses are frequently left at dining tables and waiting areas. Report to the business and the police for thoroughness.
Local Community Channels
Lost and found posts pop up on these platforms. ReportLost alerts these communities on your behalf.
Neighbors post and share lost item sightings; your report can be cross-posted here.
County-wide lost and found group with active moderators and community responses.
Regional pet lost network; critical for dogs and cats missing in Old Tappan.
Statewide subreddit where lost item posts sometimes get community attention and leads.
Frequently Asked Questions
How long does the Old Tappan Police Department keep lost items?
Most police departments hold lost items for 30 to 90 days before disposal. Contacting them promptly is crucial. Once you file with ReportLost, we keep your report active far longer, continuing to match it against new found items across multiple channels.
What if I lost something on an NJ Transit bus?
Report it directly to NJ Transit at 973-275-5555 or via their online lost and found form. They hold items at their facilities for a set period. ReportLost can file this report for you and monitor for matches.
How does ReportLost's matching work after I file?
Your report description is automatically cross-checked against new found item posts on social channels, community groups, and connected lost and found services. When a credible match surfaces, we alert you immediately so you can follow up.
Do I need to file a police report to use ReportLost?
No. ReportLost can file on your behalf with the Old Tappan Police Department, or you can file independently and use ReportLost for ongoing search and community alert. Either way, your report stays active during the search period.
What if I lost a pet in Old Tappan?
Time is critical. Contact Tyco Animal Control at 201-652-4554 immediately and alert local pet networks on Facebook and Nextdoor. ReportLost has a dedicated lost pet report option that prioritizes animal alerts and extends active monitoring for 12 months.
Is ReportLost.org official? Do I still need to call the police?
ReportLost is an independent service, not affiliated with the Old Tappan Police Department or any government agency. We work alongside official channels, not instead of them. Filing with us ensures your report reaches local authorities and community networks simultaneously, and stays active longer than a single police call would. For items of high value or clear evidence of theft, an official police report is always recommended.
Lost & found in nearby cities
Don't Let Your Lost Item Slip Away
The first few hours matter, but your search doesn't end there. With ReportLost, you file once and your report keeps working for you for months, automatically matching against new found items so you can focus on your day instead of constantly checking.
Start my report →ReportLost.org is an independent service and is not affiliated with the Old Tappan Police Department, Bergen County, NJ Transit, Newark Airport, Tyco Animal Control, or any other government or private entity mentioned. We work to connect your lost item report to official channels and community networks on your behalf, but we do not operate, control, or manage these agencies' systems. Always contact the appropriate local authority directly for items of significant value or suspected theft.