Lost something in New Milford? Report it once and keep searching.
One report goes straight to the New Milford Police Department, NJ Transit (if you lost it on the bus), and local community channels. Your report stays active for up to 12 months, matching new found items automatically so you don't have to check every day.
What did you lose?
If there isn’t an adequate suggestion, select “Other – My item isn’t listed” and enter the item’s category. You can provide details later.
Publishing your report is free and your details stay private. The assisted search is a separate paid service, described in the Terms.
Recent activity
Across the United States
- Wrislet clutch gray/silver bag with documents · Chicago, IL, October 8
- Ring TM on top · Greensboro, NC, October 8
- Keys · Sarasota, FL, October 8
- Keys · Brookline, MA, October 7
- Camera · Monterey, CA, October 7
Local contact details reviewed on July 29, 2026.
How it works
You file one report
Tell us what you lost, where, and when. No need to juggle phone numbers or hunt for the right form. We gather what you need.
We route it to the right places
Your report reaches the New Milford Police Department, NJ Transit (if applicable), and goes live on community platforms so locals can help spot it.
Your report keeps searching
For your entire search period, your report automatically matches against new found items posted across local channels. You get alerts if a match looks promising, so you can rest while we keep looking.
Where your lost item might be
New Milford has multiple systems for lost items. Here's where to look and who to call.
New Milford Police Department
The police handle lost and found reports for items lost around town. You can file in person, call with details, or submit a property loss report. We generate the right information and point you to the right desk so your report gets filed correctly.
NJ Transit Lost & Found
If you left your item on a New Milford bus or NJ Transit vehicle, use their online form or phone line. We tell you what info they'll need and confirm your report reaches the right depot.
New Milford Borough Hall
The borough office can direct you to the right department or help with items lost at municipal events. We make sure your inquiry reaches the proper staff member on the first try.
Newark Airport (EWR)
If your loss happened at Newark Airport, their dedicated lost and found office retrieves and ships items. We help you file the claim with the right airport department.
Lost Pet?
If you've lost a dog or cat, the West Milford Animal Shelter and local animal control are your first stops. They post found animals on social media and hold them during their window. file a priority lost pet report
⚠️ Spotted incorrect or outdated information? Let us know so we can review it.
Ready to report your loss?
The sooner you submit, the sooner our system starts matching your item against found reports. Once your report is live, you can step away knowing it's actively searching for you.
Report my lost item →Losing something in New Milford can feel chaotic. You've got to call the police department, check with NJ Transit if it was on the bus, dig through local Facebook groups, and keep refreshing for days hoping someone found your wallet, ring, or phone. Each place works separately, and you end up repeating the same details over and over.
ReportLost condenses that whole process into one submission. We know exactly which precinct covers New Milford, how to notify transit, and where your lost item is most likely to turn up. Better yet, your report stays active and keeps hunting for a match automatically, so once you've filed it, you can move on with your day and trust the system to find your item.
Common places people lose things in New Milford
Lost items turn up in different places depending on where you were. Knowing the area helps you narrow your search.
Downtown & River Road
The heart of New Milford, where shops, restaurants, and borough services are clustered. Wallets and phones are frequently left at storefronts and Borough Hall.
NJ Transit Bus Routes
Items left on buses are recovered at the transit depot. Call NJ Transit right away if you remember your route number and the time.
Milford Avenue & Shopping Areas
Retail districts where bags, purses, and glasses get left behind. Check with individual merchants first, then file a police report.
Parks & Recreation Areas
Outdoor spaces where rings, bracelets, and phones slip away. Local parks are patrolled, and items sometimes make their way to the police property office.
Residential Neighborhoods
Items lost on walks or during neighborhood events often get turned in to police. Posting in local community groups speeds up the process.
Community help
Local Facebook groups and Reddit threads are where neighbors post found items and share tips. Posting your loss here gives you peer eyes on the ground.
Active Facebook group for lost and found pets across the region
New Jersey Reddit community where locals post and share lost item alerts
Search for New Milford or Bergen County lost and found groups for general items
Neighborhood app where residents post lost and found items in your area
Questions about lost items in New Milford
How long does the police department hold a lost item before disposing of it?
New Milford Police keeps lost property for a set period before disposal. Call (201) 261-1400 to confirm the hold window for your specific item and precinct.
What should I do if I left something on an NJ Transit bus?
Call the NJ Transit Lost & Found at (973) 275-5555 as soon as possible with the route number, date, and time. You can also submit a report online at lostandfound.njtransit.com. Have your trip details ready to speed up the search.
Can I file a lost report online with the New Milford Police Department?
New Milford Police accepts reports by phone (201) 261-1400 or in person at 112 Patrolman Ray Woods Drive. Check their website at newmilfordnjpd.org for the most up-to-date filing options.
Where do I claim a found item once it's reported to the police?
Items are held at the New Milford Police Department property office. You'll need to visit in person or call to verify your item was turned in, and bring ID to claim it.
Do local shelters post lost pets on social media?
Yes. The West Milford Animal Shelter posts found animals on Facebook and Pawboost. Check their pages regularly if you've lost a dog or cat, and call (973) 728-2859 to confirm they have your pet.
Is ReportLost.org official or does it replace filing with the police?
ReportLost.org is an independent service that makes reporting easier and keeps your report actively searching. We're not the police or affiliated with any government agency. Filing with us routes your information to the official channels you'd contact anyway, but it saves you the phone calls and paperwork. You're always welcome to file directly with police if you prefer, and many people do both.
Lost & found in nearby cities
Stop searching alone. Report it now.
Every hour counts, but once your report is filed, you don't have to spend hours refreshing web pages. Let your report work for you for the next six to twelve months while you move forward.
Start my report →ReportLost.org is an independent service and is not affiliated with the New Milford Police Department, NJ Transit, Newark Airport, West Milford Animal Shelter, or any other government or municipal agency mentioned on this page. We route your report to the official channels and community spaces where lost items are typically reported, but we do not store items, conduct investigations, or make arrests. Always contact the relevant local authority directly if you need immediate assistance.