Lost something in Islamorada? Here is who holds found property.
One report reaches the Monroe County Sheriff's Office, local Lost & Found Upper Keys community channels, and active social networks. Your report stays active, keeping an eye out for matches so you don't have to.
What did you lose?
If there isn’t an adequate suggestion, select “Other – My item isn’t listed” and enter the item’s category. You can provide details later.
Publishing your report is free and your details stay private. The assisted search is a separate paid service, described in the Terms.
Recent activity
Florida : the legal window is 90 days once the item is in law enforcement custody. Hotels, airports and theme parks set their own, often much shorter, retention policies. (Florida Statutes ch. 705)
Across the United States
- Wrislet clutch gray/silver bag with documents · Chicago, IL, October 8
- Ring TM on top · Greensboro, NC, October 8
- Keys · Sarasota, FL, October 8
- Keys · Brookline, MA, October 7
- Camera · Monterey, CA, October 7
Local contact details reviewed on October 7, 2026.
How ReportLost works in Islamorada
You report your loss
Tell us what you lost, where, and when. Whether it's a wallet, ring, or keys left behind at a local restaurant or dock, we gather the details needed to route your case properly.
We notify the right channels
Your report is sent directly to the Monroe County Sheriff's Office, the Village of Islamorada, relevant local lost and found offices, and posted to active community networks. No more calling each place separately.
Your report keeps searching
For 12 months, your report remains active and automatically cross-checks new found item posts, marketplace listings, and community alerts. You'll get notified the moment a credible match surfaces, so you can focus on your day while we help bring your item home.
Where to report and search in Islamorada
Here are the main channels and offices that handle lost and found reports. ReportLost connects you to all of them automatically.
Monroe County Sheriff's Office
Islamorada contracts with the Monroe County Sheriff for all law enforcement. The Islamorada Substation and the Sheriff's Office both maintain a found property log. We generate and send your report directly to the right desk and let you know which location covers your loss area.
Found Property Info|Sheriff's Office Non-Emergency|Islamorada Substation
Village of Islamorada
The Village Clerk's office and Village Council handle municipal records and community coordination. When you file through ReportLost, we ensure the Village is notified so local officials can assist in spreading the word through their networks and bulletin boards.
Community & Social Networks
The Lost & Found Upper Keys Facebook group and Islamorada Reddit communities are where locals and visitors post and search for missing items daily. ReportLost publishes your report to these channels and monitors them continuously for matches, so you don't spend hours scrolling yourself.
Lost Pets in the Upper Keys
If you've lost a cat or dog, time is critical. Monroe County animal services and the Lost and Found Pets Florida Keys community on Facebook are your first resources. Our team coordinates with these networks to amplify your pet's alert. For the fastest response and specialized support, file a priority lost pet report.
⚠️ Spotted incorrect or outdated information? Let us know so we can review it.
Every hour counts, but you're not alone
The sooner you report a lost ring, bracelet, wallet, or other item, the sooner our network springs into action. Once your report is in, the Monroe County Sheriff's Office and local community channels are notified, and your report starts its active search. You can relax knowing the system is working for you.
Report my lost item →Losing something on the islands feels isolating, especially when you're not sure where to turn. Islamorada's shared services across the Village and Monroe County mean that reporting a lost wallet, purse, ring, or phone bounces between the Sheriff's Office, the Village Clerk, and scattered community groups. Most people end up calling multiple offices, repeating their story each time, and then checking Facebook and local channels daily on their own.
ReportLost simplifies this. One submission connects your report to the Monroe County Sheriff's Office, the Village authorities, and the active Lost & Found Upper Keys community on Facebook. But here's the bigger relief: your report doesn't stop searching after you hit submit. It stays active for your entire search period, automatically monitoring new found item posts and alerts, so you're not stuck refreshing community pages every morning. If someone finds your bracelet or keys and posts it online, we match it to your description and alert you. Act quickly, let our network handle the legwork, and breathe easier knowing the search continues behind the scenes.
Common places to lose items in Islamorada
Pinpoint where you lost your item to help speed up recovery.
Islamorada Waterfront & Docks
Docks, marinas, and boat ramps along Overseas Highway where wallets, phones, and personal items slip away during water activities.
Local Restaurants & Bars
Establishments along the main tourist corridor where purses, keys, and glasses are commonly left behind on tables or at the bar.
Shopping Areas
Retail districts and small shops where items are misplaced during shopping or left in fitting rooms.
Parks & Recreation Areas
Public beaches, nature trails, and outdoor spaces where jewelry and personal belongings are lost during recreation.
Hotels & Accommodations
Resort and hotel properties where guests frequently leave behind items in rooms, common areas, or during checkout.
Community groups actively searching
Join these networks where islanders post lost and found items daily.
Facebook group dedicated to Islamorada and surrounding islands
Specialized community for missing cats and dogs
Reddit community for village residents and visitors
Broader Florida Keys subreddit with active lost & found discussions
Village's main Facebook page for community announcements
Frequently asked questions
Who handles lost and found reports in Islamorada?
Islamorada contracts with the Monroe County Sheriff's Office for all law enforcement. Lost items can be reported to the Sheriff's Office (305-289-2371 non-emergency) or the Islamorada Substation (305-664-6480). The Village of Islamorada also helps coordinate community searches. ReportLost notifies all these channels at once.
How long does the Sheriff's Office keep found items?
Monroe County maintains a found property log. Items are typically held for a specific period before disposal, though exact timelines vary by item type. We recommend checking with the Sheriff's Office directly at 305-289-2351 for details on your specific item. ReportLost includes this information in your report routing.
Can I search for lost items on social media?
Yes. The <strong>Lost & Found Upper Keys</strong> Facebook group and <strong>Lost and Found Pets Florida Keys</strong> are actively used by islanders. Many people post found items there within hours. ReportLost monitors these groups and alerts you if a match appears, so you don't have to check manually every day.
What if I lost my item at a restaurant or hotel?
Call the establishment directly first, as many hold items at the front desk for 24-48 hours. ReportLost also includes instructions for filing with the Sheriff's Office and posting to community networks, ensuring the item is flagged if it makes its way to a lost and found system.
What's the difference between ReportLost and calling the Sheriff's Office?
Calling the Sheriff's Office is a single report to one agency. ReportLost files your report with the Sheriff's Office, the Village, and community networks all at once, and then keeps your report active for 12 months, automatically matching it against new found items and alerts. It's the shortcut that handles the legwork for you.
Is ReportLost.org affiliated with the Monroe County Sheriff or Village of Islamorada?
No. ReportLost is an independent service that helps you report lost items and coordinates notification to local authorities and community channels. We are not an official government agency, but we work directly with the Sheriff's Office, Village authorities, and local lost and found networks to amplify your report and keep searching for matches over time.
Lost & found in nearby cities
Ready to start your search?
The sooner your report is filed and routed to the Monroe County Sheriff's Office and local community networks, the sooner Islamorada's residents and our monitoring system can help bring your lost item home. Submit your report now and let the network do the work.
Start my report →ReportLost.org is an independent service and is not affiliated with the Monroe County Sheriff's Office, Village of Islamorada, or any local government agency. We coordinate your report with official channels and community networks as a convenience to streamline your search. All official records and legal procedures remain the responsibility of the respective agencies.